Hearing Panel Decisions

Case Reports

Hearing Panel Decisions

Court of Arbitration for Sport Decision – 3 March 2025

Covered Persons: Pramod BHAGAT

Panel: Anton Jagodic (Chair), Steven Bainbridge, Ulrich Haas

Rule Violation: BWF Anti-Doping Regulations, Article 2.4 (Whereabouts)

Download: Court of Arbitration for Sport Decision


Independent Hearing Panel Decision – 15 November 2024

Covered Persons: Mr Daren LIEW, Mr Jerry GAN Wye Leong

Panel: Mr. James Kitching (Chair), Ms. Sylvia Schenk, Mr. Vincent Denonville

Rule Violation: Code on the Prevention of the Manipulation of Competitions

Appeal: The Independent Hearing Panel decision was not appealed and is therefore final.

Download: Reasoned Decision


Independent Hearing Panel Decision – 24 January 2022

Covered Persons: Mr. Li Jun Hui, Mr. Liu Yu Chen, Mr. He Ji Ting, Mr. Tan Qiang

Panel: Mr. James Kitching (Chair), Mr. Kevin Carpenter, Ms. Yuri Yagi

Rule Violation: Nov 2017 Code of Conduct in Relation to Betting, Wagering, and Irregular Match Results

Download: Reasoned Decision


Independent Hearing Panel Decision – 6 November 2020

Covered Person: Mr. Ze Young Lim

Panel: James Kitching (Chair), Rune Bård Hansen, Kevin Carpenter

Rule Violation: Code of Conduct in relation to Betting Wagering and Irregular Match Results (2012,2016,2017)

Appeal: The Independent Hearing Panel decision was not appealed and is therefore final.

Download: ZYL Hearing Panel Decision


Independent Hearing Panel Decision – 6 November 2020

Athlete: Mr. Hendra Tandjaya (INA), Mr. Ivandi Danang (INA) , Mr. Androw Yunanto (INA), Ms. Sekartaji Putri (INA), Ms. Mia Mawarti (INA), Ms. Fadilla Afni (INA), Mr. Aditiya Dwiantoro (INA), Mr. Agripinna Prima Rahmanto Putra (INA)

Panel: James Kitching (Chair), Rune Bård Hansen, Kevin Carpenter

Rule Violation: Code of Conduct in relation to Betting Wagering and Irregular Match Results (2012,2016,2017)

Appeal: The Independent Hearing Panel decision was not appealed and is therefore final.

Download: Eight INA Players Hearing Panel Decision


Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS)

Athletes: Zulfadli Zulkiffli (MAS) and Tan Chun Seang (MAS)

Hearing Date: 1 March 2019

Hearing Panel: Hon. Dr. Annabelle Bennett AO SC (President), Ms. Blondel Thompson, Ms. Susan Ahern

Rule Violation: Code of Conduct in Relations to Betting, Wagering and Irregular Match Results 2012 & 2016

Download: CAS Appeal Panel Decision


Ethics Hearing Panel Decision – 21 November 2018

Individual: Raj Gaya

Decision Date: 21 November 2018

Hearing Panel: Sylvia Schenk (Chair), Annabel Pennefather, Kevin Carpenter

Rule Violation: Statutes of the BWF applicable prior to May 2012, Statutes, Rules and/or Regulations
of the BWF applicable after May 2012 and Statutes of the BWF applicable after June 2017.

Download: Hearing Panel Decision


Ethics Hearing Panel Decision – 27 April 2018

(See also above – CAS Appeal Decision – 26 June 2019)

Athlete: Zulfadli Zulkiffli (MAS) and Tan Chun Seang (MAS)

Hearing Date: 26 & 27 February 2018

Hearing Panel: James Kitching (Chair), Sylvia Schenk, Annabel Pennefather

Rule Violation: Code of Conduct in Relations to Betting, Wagering and Irregular Match Results 2012 & 2016

Download: Hearing Panel Decision